We’re in the business of building connections between buyers and sellers.   

Bontrager Real Estate & Auction Service

Our company is committed to utilizing the latest proven technology in marketing, inventory, and sales transactions in order to provide our customers with an auction experience that is smooth and efficient. We’re family-owned, and we’ve been making auctions happen successfully for over 80 years. We specialize in making the right connections between buyers and sellers.

Providing auction services throughout the Western New York region, we sell real estate of all kinds, antiques & collectibles, estates, vehicles, farm equipment, firearms and much more!

Please contact us with your auction questions. We would be happy to discuss how we can best serve you.

Upcoming Auctions

Storage Unit Contents Auction

Upstate Self Storage, Attica

The contents of 1 storage unit will be sold at public auction due to nonpayment of fees. Number of units is subject to change.

Live On-Site Auction
google pin icon
Upstate Self Storage, LLC, 125 Prospect Street, Attica, NY 14011
Begins:  12/18/19 at 9:00 AM EST

Storage Unit Contents Auction

Batavia Self Storage

Public auction of two storage units due to unpaid fees.  Number of units is subject to change. 

Live On-Site Auction
google pin icon
Batavia Self Storage, 45 Liberty Street, Batavia, NY 14020
Begins:  12/18/19 at 11:00 AM EST

Christmas Auction

Bontrager's Auction Center

Come join the fun for GREAT Bargains!  Raffles! Free door prize drawings & more!!  Brand new product including toys, electronics, collectibles, tools.  

Live On-Site Auction
google pin icon
8975 Wortendyke Rd., Batavia, NY 14020
Begins:  12/18/19 at 4:03 PM EST

Online Auction of Gasoline Advertising & Vintage Records

Internet Bidding Only

Vintage and reproduction advertising pieces, including gas pump globes, a great record album collection, and many collectibles.

Auction starts Dec. 20th.

Online Bidding Only

Begins:  12/20/19 at 9:00 AM EST
Ends:  01/06/20 at 6:00 PM EST

Online Real Estate Auction of 2 Parcels

4422 Hillside Rd., Pike, NY

Online bidding for 2 parcels located in the towns of Pike and Eagle

Parcel A:3-family residence w/ gambrel roof barn and 11 acres. 

Parcel B: 85.74 +/- acres of mostly wooded property with 13 acres of open/farm land in the middle.

Online Bidding Only

Begins:  01/06/20 at 6:00 PM EST
Ends:  02/17/20 at 7:00 PM EST