Wednesday Night Auction

Bontrager’s Auction Center

A new collection of consignments every week. Today’s trends and nostalgia from every decade. All the raw materials needed to repurpose, reuse and upcycle. Absentee bids are gladly accepted any weekday, but not past 2:30 p.m. on auction day. 

Began: 11/28/18 at 3:30 PM EST
Location: google pin icon 8975 Wortendyke Rd., Batavia, NY 14020


Auction starts under pavilion at 3:30 p.m.


*Absentee/left bids are gladly accepted any weekday, but no later than 2:30 p.m. on auction day.  When leaving an absentee bid, you will need the picture number from our website at Absentee bids can be phoned in at 585-343-4529, or emailed by clicking here: Leave an Absentee Bid.



Large driftwood sculpture

Many books: Arch Merrill, Alfred Hitchcock, Peanuts & other older books

Vintage magazines: Thrilling Wonder Stories; Panorama; Scribner’s, McCall’s & more

Mid-century Siamese cat lamp

Older photo albums

By-gone postcards, advertising booklets

1879 Bible by Benziger Brothers

Tonka 5 pc. fire rescue trucks

Barbie dolls and other dolls


Advertising calendars

Moore’s Rural New-Yorker back issues

Musical advertisers – South Pacific, The New Moon & more

Red Wing baseball cardboard advertisement

“Win a Trip to the Super Bowl” vintage advertisement

Paper goods & advertising pieces

2 abstract oil paintings of horses

Plastic figures & animals toys

Many wooden advertising crates including: Baker’s Cocoa, Rockwood & Co., Lion Brewery, Wood’s Hollander Coffee, JBM Inc., & more

Stereoscopes & pictures

Enterprise No. 8 coffee grinder

Wood table top desk

Sports magazines

2 drawer wood table top spool cabinet

Small Oriental style jewelry box (6 drawer)

2 World War II 2-volume book set

Sterling silver 5 pc. set – S & P shakers, creamer, bowl, butter boat

2 volume book set – History of Rochester & Monroe County, NY

Metal elephant and dog head bookends

11 pipe wrenches – New York Central, DL & W RR Co., LV RR, etc.

Glenfield Baxter milk box, Watkins Glen, NY

All wood shovel

Vintage educational slides

2 book set – New York State Museum Memoir,  Wild Flowers of NY

Sturtevant’s Notes on Edible Plants book

Vintage tin toys – trains, car, airplane, fire engine & more

Wall sconce from St. Joseph’s Church, Franklin St., Rochester, NY – recovered from 1974 fire

Old metal gum/candy dispenser

Classic model cars & model planes

Rand McNally & Co.  Map of the Eastern Hemisphere Globe series

Sankyo arcade game

Framed pictures

Ohio pure maple syrup, 1 gal. advertising tin

Suzanne Gibson 1982 Mother Goose Limited Edition set

Mid-century Dixie Cup dispenser w/cups

Kirby Heritage Super Renovation Group vacuum accessories

Berwin Jr. Executive typewriter in box

4 setting tea set – 4 cups w/saucers, tea pot, creamer & sugar

Vintage Christmas decorations in tins

China & glassware

Christmas village – butcher shop, 2-peak church, baker, horse & buggy

Tin cake carrier & 2 needlepoint tins

Costume jewelry

Vintage cameras

Stetson hat w/box

Printers’ blocks

Cigar boxes

Continuous ball-return putting green

Collectible kitchenware and cookie cutters

Wooden screw clamp

Small pet carrier

19.2 v Chicago cordless drill/drive (no charger)

Older telephone

6 pc. fireplace tool set

JC Penney Twelve Days of Christmas ornament collections

Char-Broil gas grill in box

Warner Bros. collector glasses

Thimble display case w/80+thimbles

Cherry wood jewelry box

Various Zinc Alloy pencil sharpeners – space shuttle, train car and others

3 Hawthorne village houses – Sweetheart Cottage, Stonebrook Mill, Seaside Boat House

Metal candle molds

Beanie Babies

Metal toy tractors 7 accessories

2 small microscopes

Cornell University, Ithaca, NY milk bottle

Rochester Dairy Co. milk bottle

View Masters & picture disks

View Master Entertainer projector

Marca Registrada Hohner accordion

4 pc. canister set


Vintage metal shakers & mixers

Cuisinart waffle maker

Oster bread maker

Buffet Queen percolator

RCA Victor records & other records


Brass blow torch

Toys & games

Brand new designer clothing with tags

Salt & pepper shakers

12 gal. crock

8 track tapes

Noma snow thrower

Knapp Monarch Therma Chest vintage cooler

Poloron Thermaster vintage ice chest

Lamps & floor lamps & lamp globes

Chairs, recliners

Metal toy barn

Wood cross country skis

By bidding with our auction company, you are agreeing to the following:

  • Payment is due at the close of the auction and can be made with cash, good check, Master Card or Visa. Any other payment arrangements must be made with the auctioneer prior to the close of the auction.
  • 13% buyer’s premium and NY state sales tax are added to all totals. A 3% discount is taken from the buyer’s premium if payment is made with cash or check.
  • Tax exempt buyers must present tax exempt paperwork and ID number at the time of registration.  
  • All purchased items must be removed from the premises at the close of auction.
  • Left bids will be accepted until one hour prior to the start of the auction unless otherwise posted. In order to ensure that your bids are processed, we are unable to accept bids after that time. Left bids must be picked up by the end of the auction week (close of business on Friday).  Items not picked up by the end of the week are subject to a late pick up fee. Please refer to our left bid policy ( for more information.

Bontrager’s Auction Center is located at 8975 Wortendyke Road. From Route 33 turn south on Wortendyke Road (3.5 miles west of Batavia). Our auction center is located about 1/2 mile from the intersection on the east side of the road.

Click on any image to view larger.

Click on any image to view larger.

Bontrager Real Estate & Auction Services Inc.

8975 Wortendyke Rd. Batavia, NY 14020

Your auction should be printing now. If not, please click here.